Black Ribbon Project Goes to Washington

D4PC "Crash Card" report:

(Although not visible in this photo--every doctor proudly wears a Black Ribbon.)

Charging the Hill

Dr. Hal Scherz's Field Report from the Capitol

Speaker of the House John Boehner prioritized a meeting with the leadership of Docs4PatientCare just before meeting with President Obama in the midst of the political fight over the Government shut down.

On April 6 & 7, a group of leaders from Docs 4 Patient Care went to Washington for meetings on Capitol Hill with Senators, Congressmen and their staff, for policy meetings and to participate in a healthcare symposium with the Galen Institute.

Docs4PatientCare staging outside the
Capitol to "Charge the Hill" on behalf
of the Doctor-Patient Relationship.

On this trip to DC, as compared to previous ones, we had no trouble arranging meetings with Senators and Congressmen. That is because after 2 years of work, they recognize that we are a bona fide organization and worthy of their time.

We would have had meetings with many more Senators and Congressmen then we did, had it not been for an imminent government shutdown, which occupied most of their time and attention.

Nonetheless, the highlight of our trip in many respects was our 30 minute meeting with Speaker of the House, John Boehner, which immediately preceded his first meeting with President Obama over the budget impasse.

Most of the time, groups come to DC with their hand out, trying to get a bigger slice of the federal pie. They gain entry into these offices because they have spent an enormous amount of money through lobbyists, who are hired guns, but have no real skin in the game.

We were received differently, because we are different.

New Congressman and
Docs4PatientCare member,
Dr. Dan Benishek came to
Washington to prevent the
trampling of the Doctor-
Patient Relationship.

We did not come asking for anything except for the opportunity to help them fix healthcare. We told them who we were (although many already knew), and what we had done. We shared with them our successes in the 2010 elections- helping Congressmen Dan Benishek MD, get elected in Michigan, and Joe Walsh in Illinois.

We shared with them our Prescription for Healthcare Reform and that we believed that with our expertise, we could help them with the healthcare message far better than policy experts or media professionals. We explained how our organization worked- which is not to have lobbyists, but instead to develop personal relationships between doctors and their elected officials in Congress.

We offered to help with Congressional testimony and to give assistance in healthcare matters that affect our patients and us every day, because as opposed to the faux doctors who gave up taking care of patients in favor of becoming bureaucrats, we are on the front lines daily. Finally, we shared a vision of what we can do in 2012 to help put people into Congress and the White House who will be serious about fixing healthcare in America. This can be done through the media but is better accomplished through the influence that we have on the 2000-10,000 patients that each of us sees in our offices and clinics.

We informed them about our new web site and how we had transformed it into the trusted source for healthcare information by keeping it current with updated daily content. Many of them already knew about this and had been following us.

This was a powerful message.

Speaker Boehner and everyone else that we met with acknowledged just how powerful it was. They all appreciated that we were there and had given up time at our practices and with our families and traveled to DC at our own expense. They all told us essentially the same thing:

1. We need a continued presence in Washington and we need to bring doctors from as many Congressional districts as possible.
2. We need to build our membership. There is a palpable need for a group like Docs 4 Patient Care, but the best way for people to notice us is to have as many members as possible.
3. We need to work to change control of Congress and the White House in 2012, otherwise, the prospects for healthcare will be bleak.

D4PC's rising influence after
the mid-term elections.

In addition to the meeting with Speaker Boehner, we met with the GOP healthcare leadership team in the House (Boehner, Cantor, McCarthy) and the Senate (McConnell). We met with Senator John Barrasso MD from Wyoming and his team, the team of Sen. Tom Coburn MD and Sen. Rand Paul MD. Also with 3 of the 5 freshmen GOP physician Congressmen- Scott DesJarlais (TN), Andy Harris (MD), and Dan Benishek (MI). We chatted with John Fleming MD (LA), Joe Wilson (SC) and John Culberson (TX). We also met with the healthcare specialists for Reps. Mike Burgess and Michelle Bachman.

We had an excellent healthcare symposium with the Galen Institute and Congressman Tom Price MD, helped out by delivering an impassioned speech about why this healthcare law is a disaster for America and what we must do to get rid of it.

The Heritage Foundation is one of our most important strategic partners and we were hosted to an afternoon session by Bridgett Wagner, the Director of Coalition Relations and attended by Galen Institute President Grace-Marie Turner to discuss Docs 4 Patient Care, healthcare policy issues and strategy, and Grace-Marie's new and excellent book- Why Obamacare is Wrong For America; an essential must read book for anyone who hopes to understand this difficult and convoluted subject.

Just a couple of other items to share-

Congressman Tom Price presents
the case to repeal ObamaCare.

We have filed an amicus brief in Virginia in support of the Virginia case against the Federal Government which challenges the mandate that people must purchase healthcare insurance in the Affordable Care Act. We are looking to get involved with other court actions in the near future.

We are in the process of forming Docs 4 Patient Care state chapters. We have chapters in Arizona, Colorado, and Illinois. We formally launched the Georgia Chapter this week. We are looking to have 20 state chapters by the end of 2011.

So there you have it.

Docs 4 Patient Care is very much real and vibrant.

We need those of you that have never joined as a member to do so- what more do we have to do to prove ourselves to you? Just go to our web site- docs4patientcare.org now and click on Become a Member.Those of you who have not sent in dues for this year- you are not a member, so please renew by clicking on the same link. (unless you signed up as a Gold Member since September).

We cannot succeed without every one of you. We will do the heavy lifting if you do not want to - just help us do it by supporting us. No one else will help you (or your patients) if you don't start now, by becoming a member.

Those who want to get into the fight- just let us know and we will give you something to do.

Thank you.

DEFUND, REPEAL, & REPLACE

The full framework of our plan for America can be viewed here. We invite all Americans to join us in the true effort to reform healthcare.

"Quality Bonuses"--Grease for the Squeaky Wheels

One hand giveth while the other taketh away--and both hands live in the White House.

— Millions of seniors in popular private insurance plans offered through Medicare will get a reprieve from some of the most controversial cuts in President Obama's healthcare law.

--LA Times 4-20-11

The ability to arbitrarily punish and reward groups and individuals is one of the key problems with politicizing an economic activity. Rule by Men instead of Rule of Law.

Once power is concentrated in the hands of the few, the threat to liberty accelerates--Newton's laws of motion applied to political power instead of mass.

While I was in Washington DC last week, several different people remarked that a key strategy for supporters of the health care control law will be to keep potential complainers happy---and quiet. The waivers, and now out-right hush money like Medicare Advantage "quality bonuses" are just two ways this will be accomplished.

There are only two ways to rid ourselves completely of this terrible law--either the Supreme Court rules it unconstitutional, or opponents take control of the government in 2012. Both of these pathways require continued popular discontent.

We must do everything we can to keep this issue fresh in the minds of voters. It truly has life and death consequences--for both our liberty and our access to affordable, trust-worthy medical care.

.

Why the ACA is wrong and must be repealed.

The Black Ribbon Project is participating in the Independent Women's Voice ObamaCare Video Contest. The deadline of midnight March 19th is approaching fast, but it's not too late to add your own original contribution. First prize is $5000---but the competition is pretty stiff. All entries will be posted on their website, however, so it's a great way to spread your personal message.

The Black Ribbon Project supports repeal of the ACA because of the way it tramples on the doctor-patient relationship--but more than that, it endangers the roots of civil society.

What a great challenge to get to meat of the matter in under one minute!

Be sure to check out the website and vote for your favorite. Some are really quite good!

IWV You Tube Channel

Shameless request: Vote for my video. From what I can tell, the winner is whoever gets the most viewer votes. Any winnings I receive will go to The Black Ribbon Project.

How to Defend Health Care Freedom

Last fall, I was invited to speak about the Black Ribbon Project at the annual meeting of the American Association of Physicians and Surgeons. I took the opportunity to share a few of my thoughts on the principles we need to promote to effectively defend health care freedom and the doctor-patient relationship. I am pleased with how much I was able to cover in just 25 minutes. Let me know what you think!

Testimony on Fiscal Consequences of PPACA

Richard Foster, Chief Actuary, Center for Medicare and Medicaid.
1/26/11 Testimony before the House Committee on the Budget


McCLINTOCK: “True or false: The two principle promises that were made in support of Obamacare were one, that it would hold costs down. True or false?”

FOSTER: “I would say false, more so than true.”

McCLINTOCK: “The other promise… was the promise that if you like your plan, you can keep it. True or false?”

FOSTER: “Not true in all cases.”

A Tale of Two Emails on repeal of the PPACA

I recently received two emails. One is from the White House with the Orwellian title, "Protecting Your New Freedoms Under the Affordable Care Act." The other, "What Repeal Really Means" was from Chris Jacobs of the Republican Policy Committee.

Read both releases carefully.

Our President claims he can offer people the chance to be free from the demands of reality by making others pick up the tab.

But no one can be free from the requirements of reality---the necessity of creating the values you need to sustain your life. Freedom is not a metaphysical concept but a political one, one whose true meaning is to be free from the coercive acts of others.

If allowed to stand, the PPACA will extend the power of government, further depriving us of the freedom we need to sustain our lives: the freedom to use our own minds, set our our values and priorities, and to act on our own choices. The PPACA will extend the current erroneous legal precedent that government can rightfully dictate the contents of private contracts and exchanges, along with regulating items we produce for our own private use as "interstate commerce" (see Wickard v. Filburn.) In addition, the government will be allowed to dictate what we must and must not purchase, and with whom, and for what price.

The PPACA is one of the biggest intrusions into our economic freedom in recent years. No individual or business will be left unaffected--and few, if any, restrainsts will be left on the power of government over our economic lives. And since freedom is of a piece, loss of economic freedoms will eventually require the erosion of freedom in all other realms.

What does repeal of ObamaCare really mean? It means resurrecting the Rule of Law and reasserting the Constitution as a limit on government power, and the purpose of government as the protector of individual rights.

The main issue is not whether or not repeal will add to the deficit, or if repeal will save jobs.

The main issue is that repeal will restore essential freedoms and take a step in the right direction of limiting the intrusion of government into our private lives.

ObamaCare must go so we can live our lives in freedom.

A solution which destroys freedom, is no true solution at all.

.

Federal Judge Rules Individual Mandate Unconstitutional

U.S. District Judge Henry E. Hudson ruled today that the individual mandate of the ACA (a.k.a. ObamaCare) is unconstitutional.

“Neither the Supreme Court nor any federal circuit court of appeals has extended Commerce Clause powers to compel an individual to involuntarily enter the stream of commerce by purchasing a commodity in the private market. In doing so, enactment of the (individual mandate) exceeds the Commerce Clause powers vested in Congress.” from newsok.com

I have previously read that due to the lack of a severablity clause, if any part of the law is ruled unconstitutional, the whole bill will have to be thrown out. Unfortunately, it turns out to be more complicated than that.

Here is the best explanation I have yet come across:

A Guide to Severability and ObamaCare

[T]he lack of a severability clause wouldn’t necessarily result in the overrule the rest of the legislation, which mostly have to do with spending and rationing — the expansion of Medicaid, Medicare cuts, and sweeping regulatory authority — and isn’t wrapped up in the mandate. This has been the Court’s approach to other issues, such as the recent Sarbanes-Oxley ruling, another law which lacked a severability clause, where they invalidated a portion of the law and allowed the rest to stand.

Some proponents of the ACA believe that the health of the individual mandate would move us closer to implementing a single payer system. (See Ezra Klein's article in today's Washington Post.) The danger of this is only too real.

The best way to prevent that from happening is to continue to speak out against ObamaCare as a whole.

Even a Supreme Court ruling that the individual mandate is unconstitutional will not save us from the multitude of other violations of life, liberty and property intimately woven throughout the ACA.

Preservation health care freedom and the sanctity of the doctor-patient relationship requires the complete REPEAL of the ACA, and the extraction of government from the business and practice of medicine.

For more analysis on today's reading see:

Individual Mandate in Heath Reform Law Ruled Unconstitutional by Federal Judge on Medscape.com

ObamaCare Is Unconstitutional by Grace-Marie Turner

Full Text of the Opinion

Health Reform Will Survive it Legal Fight by Eric H0lder and Kathleen Sebelius

.